What Philosophy Can Teach You About Living Well with Chronic Illness
Whenever I’m writing articles on the psychological aspects of living with chronic illness, from accepting your new reality to rebuilding your resilience after adversity, one phrase always pops up in the research: reframe your problems.
Not because your problems aren’t real or serious, but because the way you look at your situation matters. Your perception of what’s happening plays a big role in how you feel emotionally and how you react physically. For instance, when you see a blunder as a funny mistake that anyone could make, you’ll probably laugh or shrug it off, while considering it a colossal screw-up leaves you feeling embarrassed.
Reframing your problems sounds like a simple trick, but what exactly does it mean? Why is it helpful and how do you do it?
Time for a deep dive into the science behind reframing your problems, also known as cognitive reappraisal.
According to appraisal theory, your interpretation of events affects your emotions, physiological responses and action tendencies. The same situation perceived differently will give different responses in your body and brain. For example, when people are told to see the nerves, racing heart and sweaty palms they experience during a stressful task as functional, they have a more adaptive cardiovascular response to that stress than people who don’t get these instructions.
Psychologists call this reframe ‘cognitive reappraisal’: changing the way you feel about a situation that brings up (heavy) emotions. It’s not the same as pretending everything’s fine or pushing your feelings away. On the contrary: research on handling emotions has found that people who regularly reappraise their situation report more positive and less negative feelings, better social functioning and increased wellbeing, while people who tend to suppress their emotions show the opposite pattern.
In real life, reappraising a situation can look like telling yourself, when your medical appointment is running late, that the doctor probably needs extra time for the struggling patient ahead of you, instead of feeling disrespected and getting all worked up. That doesn’t make the waiting any more pleasant, but it can stop frustration and tension in your body from building up.

Cognitive reappraisal won’t magically make your health problems go away. But studies show that reframing life with chronic illness can actually have a positive impact on your mood, pain experience, daily functioning and identity.
A meta-analysis found that the way you think about your illness influences how you cope with being sick. The ideas you have about the symptoms, cause, consequences and course of your condition motivate you to take certain actions (or not). For example, seeing your illness as curable or controllable is (obviously) linked to improved wellbeing, better social functioning and less distress than when your health feels out of your hands.
Another way this comes up in our chronic life is the infamous fear-avoidance loop. Let’s say you’ve got a fun day planned and as you wake up, you feel this nagging pain. If your mind instantly goes into ‘This pain will ruin my entire day” mode, worrying how you’ll let your friends down or why bad things always happen to you, this fearful interpretation can make you cautious to make new plans. But inactivity and social withdrawal out of fear for more pain and disappointment will hurt your daily functioning, your mental health and overall health.
Your thoughts about pain help shape your pain experience. While ruminating about your symptoms intensifies the aching you feel, the opposite is also true: changing your beliefs about the causes and threat value of your pain may bring significant pain relief.
Reappraising bodily sensations and emotions doesn’t make your symptoms and feelings any less real or valid. And in case you needed to hear it (again): your mindset did not cause your disease. Reframing your problems just means you try not to get overwhelmed by negative assumptions and choose a more helpful narrative instead.
Changing the meaning you give to a situation doesn’t solve your problems, but it does have multiple benefits for your health and happiness:
That doesn’t mean that reframing your problems is the right coping strategy for every situation. When you can do something about the problem, it’s best to focus on problem-solving coping rather than managing your perception. And when emotions are running high, people usually prefer distraction over reappraisal.
More so, if reframing feels forced, maybe making room for painful thoughts and feelings rather than changing them, like in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, feels like a better choice.
Reframing your problems begins by admitting you do actually have a problem. You’re not trying to deny your difficulties or dismiss your feelings, you just try to look for other plausible, more constructive scenarios than subconsciously expecting the worst.
Reappraisal starts by checking what is true: sure, fatigue is stopping you from tackling your to do list, but does that really mean you’re lazy or a failure? Or are you just a human being struggling with serious health problems? And do you ‘never get anything done’ or will it just take more time and creativity?
On the other hand, toxic positivity is pretending everything is fine when it’s not. And no, thinking ‘just push through the fatigue’ and ‘with the right attitude you can make anything happen‘ is not a realistic nor sustainable mindset for living with chronic illness.
If reframing your problems ever looks like ignoring painful issues, pushing your emotions away or feeling guilty for struggling, it has slipped into toxic positivity, not cognitive reappraisal.

When you’re stressed and struggling, cognitive reappraisal is a useful strategy to support your emotional wellbeing. But how exactly do you reframe problems in real life, especially when you’re chronically ill?
Reframing only works when you start from honesty. Unlike toxic positivity, you shouldn’t push painful thoughts and feelings away; you just don’t want to get stuck in a negative spiral. If your friends post pictures of a weekend away that you couldn’t join, don’t scroll on and let the envy eat you up. Instead, state the ‘facts’ to yourself: “It hurts that I’m missing out and it’s perfectly normal to feel sad about that.”
Your mind is constantly processing and interpreting everything that’s happening around you. So ask yourself: “What am I telling myself this means?”
A small study found that viewing pain as harmful predicts more anxiety and higher perceived pain than viewing it as a challenge. That’s just a correlation, but it shows that the story you tell yourself matters.
That’s why reframing your problems begins with becoming aware of your inner dialogue. Because thinking you’re worthless and lazy for needing a nap has a different effect on your wellbeing compared to seeing rest as a vital part of your recovery plan.
Once you’ve noticed the story you’re telling yourself, you should check if it’s accurate and helpful.
Your thought patterns influence how you’ll feel about what’s happened and which actions you will take next.

Sometimes you’re too close to the problem to see things clearly. Creating some mental distance can help to see things from a different perspective.
According to psychological experiments, using your own name or “you” during self-talk leads people to see upcoming stressors as less threatening and more as a challenge. For example, the next time you’re experiencing post-exertional malaise, tell yourself: “[Your name], you’re exhausted. What do you need today to recover and support your wellbeing?”
When you’re waiting for test results and your heart’s pounding, it helps to think: “My body is simply getting ready to process the news”. Seeing stress arousal as an adaptive strategy to be ready for action can actually lead to healthier cardiovascular responses. And trying not to immediately expect the worst when your chronic pain flares-up again, can also improve your pain experience.
But that does not mean that you should ignore or reframe every symptom. Acute health problems like chest pain, difficulty breathing, numbness in your limbs, sudden confusion or severe abdominal pain require immediate medical attention. But even issues like unexplained weight loss, unusual bleedings and changes in your bowel movement may be signs of underlying illnesses.
So do not downplay potential serious symptoms. When in doubt, have it checked out.
Cognitive reappraisal is a helpful tool when your problem is mostly outside of your control, like losing friendships or catching a virus on top of your usual health problems. But when there is something you can do to change your situation for the better, you should use problem-solving skills like researching, making decisions or proactive communication.
That’s why you should make two lists: what you can’t change about your situation (like an unexpected flare-up) and what you still can do (pacing your energy, managing your symptoms as well as you can and asking for help when you need it).

When some people get a compliment that does not match with how they view themselves (like getting told they’re beautiful when they hate the way they look), it can trigger feelings of discomfort or shame rather than positivity. The same can be true for when you try to talk yourself into a reframe that sounds too good to be true. Going from “I’ll never get better again” to “I’m positive I will conquer this disease” is a 180-degree turn, and it can be even harder to believe in a more positive outcome when you make internal statements that may not come true.
Instead, choose a more realistic reframe you can actually believe, such as “Let’s take this one step to improve my sleep/diet/range of motion/mental health and take it from there, slowly but steadily.”
Cognitive reappraisal looks for the middle ground between doom scenarios like “nobody will ever take me serious” and “my fatigue makes me a useless person who’ll never find love” and toxic positivity statements.
There’s nothing more frustrating than people reframing an upsetting situation for you, saying“it could be worse” when your entire life has been turned upside down by chronic illness. When emotions are running high, you need to process your feelings first and calm down before trying cognitive reappraisal.
Take your time to cry, talk to your best friend or take a short walk to clear your head. Only once you’ve calmed down, do you start with naming what’s true and what a more constructive reframe could look like.
You have every right to grieve not being able to pursue your passion anymore before you look into other ways to express that part of your personality.
When you find yourself getting stuck in negative thinking patterns, overwhelmed with heavy emotions or numb from all the heaviness, please remember that you do not have to do this alone. A psychologist trained in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) can help you to process these feelings and reframe your problems over time, while Acceptance and Commitment Therapy guides you through the painful situations you cannot change. There are also pain-reprocessing programs for people struggling with chronic pain to better manage their condition, so ask your doctor if that could be beneficial for you.
Especially if you’re struggling with depressive thoughts or symptoms of anxiety, always contact a medical professional to get you the help you deserve.
You can’t think your way out of a chronic illness (or an acute one for that matter). But the way you interpret events in your life can influence how heavy it feels and how confident you feel about being able to handle the obstacles on your way. Reframing your problems (without toxic positivity!) gives you a sense of control in a challenging situation. It does not stop the pain you feel, but it can ease your suffering.
You can find more related tips in ‘The Beginner’s Guide to Changing Your Negative Thoughts’ and ‘How to Stop Pain Catastrophizing during Flare-Ups’. Or get more in-depth advice delivered to your inbox every week by signing up for The Health Sessions’ free newsletter: